Fly Fishing Utah’s Fabled Green River
Fish averaging 16-18 inches are commonly caught from drift boats on the Green River.
I arrived in Dutch John, Utah the third weekend in June, looking for Big Daddy Brown and friends in the fabled tail waters of the Green River below Flaming Gorge Reservoir. After leaving the flat lands of central Kansas in my rearview mirror, I drove hard for thirteen hours while crossing three states on a 935-mile marathon. Catching a catnap in a truck stop, I showed up in Dutch John at sunup the following morning.
Located near the three corners of Wyoming, Colorado, and Utah, Dutch John would most likely cease to exist if not for a constant stream of vacationers using the lake, and an army of fly fishermen testing their skills below Flaming Gorge Reservoir. Little bigger than two gas stations and a red light, Dutch John is a small isolated village, so remote, that you had best be going to Dutch John with an exacting purpose to ever want to end up there. It is the jumping off place for fly fisherman wanting to experience the crystal clear waters of the fabled Green.
Utah’s Green River is a Mecca for those who worship the dry fly. Okay. Okay. For those who wish to bounce a nymph, we won’t kick you out of the club, just yet. The Green will rightfully tempt you to become a fully initiated member of those among us, who fish hard and fish dry. Seeing a mammoth brown slowly rise to the surface, opening his mouth and twisting his neck to devour your fly, puts a charge into your pants that you cannot get any other way. Did I just say that fishing a dry fly on the Green is better than sex? Almost.
What embodies the Green as such a storied tail water, is the incredible number of fish per mile and the absurd growth rates of these wild browns inhabiting the river. This is due to the large amount of aquatic hatches and food available along its banks. If you are ever lucky enough to fish the Green, don’t be surprised if most of the fish that stretch your line average sixteen inches or better.
That is why every summer throngs of fly fishermen, decked out in their fancy fishing duds, stand in the parking lot at Trout Creek Flies to talk shop before heading down to the water. If clothes could actually catch fish, Dutch John would be the place for a casual observer to write a book about it. As if on command, a daily parade of noteworthy guides, towing drift boats, begin pulling into the parking lot of Trout Creek Flies, pausing just long enough to pick up these expectant anglers, who have been dreaming about monster browns in their sleep since before last Christmas.
Should you choose to fish and wade, without the advantage of a drift boat and the aid of a trained guide, the fellows inside Trout Creek Flies will tell you what flies the guides say are “hot,” and also give you the latest tips for catching fish. There is easy access along the river while walking any of the six miles up the river trail from Little Hole to the dam. For those fishermen a bit more adventurous, this hike up the canyon offers a bit more solitude and waters less fished. You can also take a left turn from the boat ramp at Little Hole and head down river to fish the B section of the river. Either option offers a menu of incredible fishing. Much further downstream from the B section, lies the most remote portion of the river, accessible primarily by drift boat. The C-section of the river carries with it all the lore of days gone by and Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid. It is in this three-corner area of Utah, Wyoming, and Colorado that the outlaw gang made history by outrunning lawmen from the three adjoining states. The fishing on the C is said to be a bit slower than the A or B sections of the river, but it is also rumored that the lower portion of the river is where monsters lurk.
Most betting men would pick mid to late June to fly fish the Green because of the massive Cicada hatches that can turn June from a truly good fishing month into one of epic proportions. It is the big terrestrials that the browns gorge themselves on all summer that makes the Green such an extreme dry fly destination. Combine the quality of available terrestrial insects with the large aquatic hatches that appear on the river during the heat of summer, and the Green comes alive with bugs.
I fished the banks using hoppers, ants, and black crickets.
This year proved a little different. The cool and damp weather before my arrival had not only slowed any hope of the usual appearance of the cicada onslaught, but few if any notable bug hatches had yet to appear on the river to date. I found guides standing in small circles praying to the bug gods for warmer days. Some went as far as to announce that the cicadas would stay in the ground for another year. Was I in Utah? This was the first official day of summer and the locals seemed almost ecstatic to see a ray of sunshine overhead, instead of viewing a constant threat of rain. The damper weather had combined with an early snowmelt, which had resulted in much higher than normal water tables in the lake. The high lake water resulted in fluctuating amounts of water to be discharged down stream from the dam. Things weren’t running like a Swiss watch. This irritated the guides and the lack of bugs seemed to weigh on everyone’s psyche. I asked myself, “Would there still be fish in the river?”
Although few aquatic hatches were actually happening on the river itself, these fish seem to thrive on ants, crickets, and hoppers along its banks. Fishermen were beginning to take big browns in good numbers, even if not in the epic proportions of past memories. The fish were there. Many of the bugs were simply on vacation. The only difference seemed that the fly shops were pushing different insect patterns rather than the typical cicada, and without a specified hatch, the guides found themselves searching for a silver bullet in their arsenal of ammunition.
By now, you may find yourself scratching your head and asking what is the big deal about the Cicada hatch on the Green. These noisy critters are large, clunky, and often overlooked by fly fishermen. When these bug-eyed creatures crawl out of the ground in summer the trees come alive with a cacophony noise up and down the river. Cicadas cannot fly very well and their futile attempts at flight result in crashes into the river. The cicada hatch makes for an ongoing buffet for the trout as long as it lasts. Generally, that is from the middle of June through early July.
I had reserved a guide with Spinner Fall Guide Service out of Dutch John. I came to learn the hard way that it is best to book early when fishing the Green. Many slots were no longer available by the time I picked up the phone in early April. Hey dude, why get into a hurry? I had originally planned to partake in two days of guided trips on the river, but was only able to schedule one float during the week that I was to be in Dutch John. I got the last available slot with Spinner Fall Guide Service for a one-day gig fishing both the A and B sections of the river. Lucky me!
My guide was a fellow named Jeromey with a quirky personality as big as the state of Utah and as twisted as all of Wyoming. Best of all, Jeromey loved to fish hard. It was the extreme skiing of northern Utah that had first lured Jeromey away from his home state of Maine. Migrating to Park City in the mid 90’s, Jeromey found guiding to his liking during the summers when he wasn’t on the slopes. Jeromey seems to approach fishing with the same degree of extreme intensity that he attacks fresh powder. I often say that life is full of priorities, and Jeromey has found his. He works as a bartender at night so that he can ski all day. Once the snow finally melts, Jeromey calls the rivers from Park City to Dutch John his home. I believe that no one can upstage Jeromey’s intensity on the river. He has worked as a professional fly fishing guide the past fifteen years and knows the Green like the back of his hand. I was not to be disappointed.
The A section of the river flows through a beautiful red rock canyon.
The first thing Jeromey told me as he crawled behind the wheel and we drove to the launch, was that there was no Cicada hatch and not to worry. We might not find a lot of suicide fish willing to eat anything that hit the water, and we might actually have to work hard to catch fish. But we would catch fish. He promised me at least twenty-five “eats,” and the rest was up to me. Jeromey had every intention of putting me in the right drift where the fish were patiently waiting for dinner to come floating by. As he properly stated, “Fish have to eat. It is all about making it look totally natural and fooling the fish.” He took his philosophy a step further. There had been few aquatic hatches on the river, but, as always, there was an abundance of terrestrials for the fish to feed on. Jeromey explained that many of the guides would fish the banks where crickets, ants, and hoppers might easily fall into the water. So, he posed the question, “What happens to that cricket or beetle that makes it far enough to eventually be washed down stream?” Eventually those land-loving insects find themselves in the middle of the river. That is where we fished much of the time, and Jeromey’s thinking was spot on.
It did not take us long to get our first four eats, and I brought four nice browns to the net. I knew that my average was too good to be true and the next several fish got the better of me, as I totally missed setting the hook. The important thing was that Jeromey was putting me onto the fish. So what if the Cicada hatch had just totally rained on our parade. It may be rumored that a blind man can catch trout on a dry fly when the Cicada hatch is at its peak on the Green River, but that was water already under the dam as far as Jeromey was concerned and we were here to catch fish. What other river provides such an opportunity with 25,000 fish per nautical mile? We were here on this given day and Jeromey had just promised me twenty-five eats. I did not question his methods, as Jeromey delivered on his promise.
We floated sixteen miles that day, while fishing hard. Jeromey never let up. Then he almost apologized as we pulled in at the end of a very long day. It was not the best of days for the Green in June, but a bad day on the Green is all in the eye of the beholder. I thought the fishing was great. No, not epic, but hard to beat anywhere else in the lower 48. I can see where it would be easy to become a bit jaded when you are a dyed-in-the-wool guide on the Green. The fishing can truly be that good at times. My experience was great. No, there were not fish feeding on the surface everywhere around us. There were no suicide fish looking to become immortal. In fact, few surfacing feeder fish showed their faces at all. This was a day for good fishermen, and those not so good, to fish hard and show their metal on a river that gives up to those who deserve their just reward.
My hat is off to Jeromey. He is one cool cucumber, who is doing exactly what he loves to do. Life simply does not get any better than that.
The B section of the Green.
For more information on Spinner Fall Guide Service, visit Spinnerfall.com.
Fly Fish Utah is a new painting by Larry Stephenson. It is the fourth in a series of vintage license plates heralding the great fly fishing of the western mountain states. View this and other fun art at WWW.LSTEPHENSON.COM. Prints are available for order.


















